An Examination of the Suitability of Transactional, Transformational and Situational Leadership Theories in Evaluating the Role of Gender in Determining the Leadership Style: a Comparison and Contrast of Three Leadership Theories

Terrance Brian Woods


The purpose of this paper is to evaluate suitability of transactional, transformational and situational leadership theories in evaluating the role of gender as a determinant leadership style and organizational performance. These three theories were compared and contrasted and the research findings synthesized to ascertain the theory most appropriate for explaining leadership style within the context of gender. While these theories were posited many decades ago, the study showed that they continue to provide an important framework for leaders in the 21st century. Transformational leadership theory was however deemed most appropriate across alternate scenarios.


Gender; leadership; leadership style; transformational leadership; transactional leadership; situational leadership

Full Text:



Avolio BJ, Bass BM and Jung DI. Re-examining the components of transformational and transactional leadership using the Multifactor Leadership. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology.1999, 72:441–462

Avolio BJ, Walumbwa FO, & Weber TJ. Leadership: Current theories,research, and future directions. AnnualReview of Psychology. 2009, 60(1):421–449

Ayman R & Korabik K. Leadership. American Psychologist. 2010, 65(3):157-170

Bass BM. Bass &Stogdill’s handbook of leadership, 3rd edition. New York, NY: Free Press, 1990

Bass M. Leadership performance beyond expectations. New York, NY: Academic Press, 1985

Bass M. The Bass handbook of leadership: Theory, research, & managerial applications (4th ed.). New York, NY: Free Press, 2008

Bass BM & Avolio BJ. Improving organizational effectiveness through transformational leadership. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1994

Breevaart K, BakkerA, Hetland J, Demerouti E, Olsen OK & Espevik R. Daily transactional and transformational leadership and daily employee engagement. Journal of Occupational & Organizational Psychology. 2014, 87(1):138-157.

Burns JM. Leadership. New York: Harper & Row, 1978

Bycio P, Hackett RD & Allen JS. Further Assessments of Bass's (1985) Conceptualization of Transactional and Transformational Leadership. Journal Of Applied Psychology. 1995, 80(4): 468-478

Conger JA. Charismatic leadership. In A. Bryman, D. Collinson, K. Grint, B. Jackson & M. Uhl-Bien (Eds.), The SAGE handbook of leadership (pp. 86-102). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2011

Conger JA, Kanungo RN and Menon ST. Charismatic leadership and follower effects. Journal of Organizational Behavior. 2000, 21:747-767

Day DV. Leadership development. In A. Bryman, D. Collinson, K. Grint, B. Jackson & M. Uhl-Bien (Eds.), The SAGE handbook of leadership (pp. 37-50). Thousand Oaks, CA Sage, 2011

Day DV. Executive Selection Is a Process Not a Decision. Industrial & Organizational Psychology. 2009, 2(2): 159-162

Day DV & Harrison MM. A multilevel, identity-based approach to leadership development. Human Resource Management Review. 2007, 17(4):360 373

DeRue DS & Wellman N. Developing leaders via experience: The role of developmental challenge, learning orientation, and feedback availability. Journal of Applied Psychology. 2009, 94(4): 859-875

Fernandez CF &Vecchio RP. Situational leadership theory revisited: A test of an Leadership Quarterly. 1997, 8(1): 67

Ghasabeh MS, Soosay C & Reaiche C. The Emerging Role of Transformational Leadership..Journal Of Developing Areas. 2015, 49(6):459-467

Glynn MA & DeJordy R. Leadership through an organizational behavior lens: A look at the last half-century of research. In N. Nohria, & R. Khurana (Eds.), Handbook of leadership and practice (pp. 119-158). Boston, MA: Harvard Business Press, 2010

Graeff CL. (1983). The Situational Leadership Theory: A Critical View. Academy Of Management Review. 1983, 8(2), 285-291

Greer CR &Virick M. Diverse succession planning: Lessons from the industry leaders. Human Resource Management. 2008, 47(2):351-367

Groves K & LaRocca M. An Empirical Study of Leader Ethical Values, Transformational and Transactional Leadership, and Follower Attitudes Toward Corporate Social Responsibility. Journal Of Business Ethics. 2011, 103(4): 511-528

Hater JJ, Bass BM. (1988). Superiors' evaluations and subordinates' perceptions of transformational and transactional leadership. Joumal of Applied Psychology. 73:695-702

Hay I. Leadership of stability and leadership of volatility: Transactional and transformational leaderships compared. Academic Leadership: The Online Journal. 2007, 65(2):67-69

Hersey P, Blanchard KH & Johnson DW. Management of Organizational Behavior:Utilizing Human Resources, (7th ed). Upper Saddle River, N.J., Prentice Hall, 1996

Johansen BP. Situational Leadership: A Review of the Research. Human Resource Development Quarterly. 1990, 1(1):73-85

Judge TA & Piccolo RF. Transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analytic test of their relative validity. Journal of Applied Psychology. 2004, 89(5):755-768

Keskes I. Relationship between leadership styles and dimensions of employee organizational commitment: A critical review and discussion of future directions. Intangible Capital. 2014, 10(1):26-51

Landis EA, Hill D & Harvey MR. A Synthesis of Leadership Theories and Styles. Journal Of Management Policy & Practice. 2014, 15(2):97-100

Larsson J & Vinberg S. Leadership behaviour in successful organisations: Universal or situation-dependent?.Total Quality Management & Business Excellence. 2010, 21(3):317-334

Latham JR. Leadership for Quality and Innovation: Challenges, Theories, and a Framework for Future Research. Quality Management Journal. 2014, 21(1):11-15

Leong LYC. Is transformational leadership universal? A meta-analytical investigation of multifactor leadership questionnaire means across cultures. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies. 2011, 18(2):164-174

Lewis D, Medland J, Malone S, Murphy M, Reno K, & Vaccaro G. Appreciative Leadership: Defining Effective Leadership Methods. Organization Development Journal. 2006, 24(1):87-100

Liu J, Liu X & Zeng X. Does transactional leadership count for team innovativeness? Journal of Organizational Change Management. 2011, 24(3):282-298.

Malos R. The most important leadership theories. Annals Of EftimieMurgu University Resita, Fascicle II, Economic Studies. 2012, 413-420.

McCleskey JA. Situational, Transformational, and Transactional Leadership and Leadership Development. Journal Of Business Studies Quarterly. 2014, 5(4):117-130

Morgeson FP, DeRue DS & Karam EP. Leadership in teams: A functional approach to understanding leadershipstructures and processes. Journal of Management. 2010, 36(1):5-39

Novac C & Bratanov CI. The impact of the leadership style on the organizational climate in a public entity. Management Dynamics in the Knowledge Economy. 2014, 2(1):155-179

Raja AS & Palanichamy P. Leadership Styles and its Impact on Organizational Commitment. Journal Of Commerce.2011, 3(4):15-23

Rowold J &Rohmann A. Transformational and transactional leadership styles, followers' positive and negative emotions, and performance in German nonprofit orchestras. Nonprofit Management & Leadership. 2009, 20(1):41-59

Seibert SE, Wang G & Courtright SH. Antecedents and consequences psychological and team empowerment in organizations: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Applied Psychology. 2011, 96:981-1003

Silva A. What Do We Really Know About Leadership?.Journal Of Business Studies Quarterly. 2014, 5(4), 1-4

Tourish D. Challenging the Transformational Agenda: Leadership Theory in Transition. Management Communication Quarterly . 2008, 21 (4):522-528

Virick M & Greer CR. Gender diversity in leadership succession: Preparing for the future. Human Resource Management. 2012, 51(4):575-600

Whittington J & Galpin TJ. The engagement factor: Building a high-commitment organization in a low-commitment world. Journal of Business Strategy. 2010, 31(5):14-24

Yukl G. Managerial Leadership: A Review of Theory and Research. Journal Of Management. 1989, 15(2):251

Yukl G. How leaders influence organizational effectiveness. The Leadership Quarterly. 2008, 19(6):708-722

Yukl G. Contingency theories of effective leadership. In A. Bryman, D. Collinson, K. Grint, B. Jackson & M. Uhl-Bien (Eds.), The SAGE handbook of leadership (pp. 286-298). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2011

Yukl G. Effective Leadership Behavior: What We Know and What Questions Need More Attention. Academy Of Management Perspectives. 2012, 26(4): 66-85

Yukl G, &Mahsud R. Why flexible and adaptive leadership is essential. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research. 2010, 62(2):81-93

Zhu W, Sosik JJ, Riggio RE & Yang B. Relationships between transformational and active transactional leadership and followers' organizational identification: The role of psychological empowerment. Journal of Behavioral and Applied Management. 2012, 13(3):186


  • There are currently no refbacks.

AJMS (ISSN 2689-2022) ©2012-2021. All rights reserved. Published by Ivy Union Publishing, 3204 Valley Rush Dr, Apex, North Carolina 27502, United States